Home  |  Subscribe to this RSS feed
About This Blog

Nashville's Pancake Pantry

Submitted by Maria White, January 7, 2010
The Pancake Pantry, Nashville
I love all kinds of food (I don’t discriminate!), but breakfast fare is by far my favorite. When I travel, I usually try to check out at least a few local eateries with standout morning menus. So, on a recent business trip to Nashville, I chowed down at the Pancake Pantry, said to dole out the yummiest pancakes in town. (Some devotees go so far as to claim the flapjacks doled out at the Pantry are among the world’s best.)

The local A.M. institution is in Hillsboro Village, a colorful neighborhood abutting Vanderbilt University. When I arrived, there was a short line, but it moved quickly, and I was seated within 10 minutes. (Actually, the wait for a server was longer, and when she finally arrived, she was all business.) Although the bulk of the menu features pancakes to match every palate—from sweet potato pancakes to ultra-thin blintzes—I ordered an egg platter with a side of plain, old-fashioned buttermilk pancakes.

The server headed to the kitchen. Then, about 20 minutes went by. I looked around and noticed not too many The Pancake Pantryother customers had their food—never a good sign. I went to the bathroom, hoping that when I returned to my seat, my food would be there waiting for me. No such luck.

Finally the server reappeared, and she was bearing gifts. My dish—the Grill Cook’s Medley—looked so delicious that I dug in immediately, momentarily forgetting to snap a picture. Here’s how the Pantry menu describes the overloaded breakfast plate: “One of our best sellers. Put together mounds of hash browns with onions, green peppers, tomatoes and ham—all grilled up crisp. Add to that two kinds of melted cheese and topped with two fried eggs. Just break the yolks and spread picante sauce all over.”

Though there’s a lot of stacking going on, the Grill Cook’s Medley isn’t just a pile of mush. Everything on my plate was cooked perfectly. The eggs weren’t runny or greasy, the potatoes were zesty, and the cheese was gooey and plentiful. I hated to do it, but halfway through the meal I had to stop myself because I didn’t want toThe Pancake Pantry run out of belly room for the pancakes.

A huge mound of butter—way too much for my needs—was scraped onto the side of the flapjacks. I added the syrup, which was in a tall glass container with a pour spout (très cool), and cut a few pieces. Each fluffy bite melted in my mouth, and I was definitely pleased. However, I can’t say I was all that impressed. These pancakes looked and tasted similar to ones I could get at any decent IHOP, and while I do love that national chain, I expected something a little more unique from a local neighborhood eatery. In addition, I felt the service was somewhat slow and, unfortunately, The Pancake Pantrythis wasn’t because my waitress was super hospitable. (She wasn’t rude, but she also wasn’t overly friendly.)

I finished up then waited up front to pay. Behind the cash register, a sign caught my eye: “Sun, rain or shine, there’s always a line.” The cute little ditty succinctly expressed my own opinion of the Pancake Pantry. Still, my experience, though drawn-out, hadn’t been that time-consuming. I certainly was glad I wasn’t part of the sluggish procession of would-be patrons now lining up at the front door.

All in all, I liked the place. Any establishment that puts the word “pancake” right in its name is OK with me (and, apparently, public figures like the Jonas Brothers and Mitt Romney feel the same way).  If I’m ever in Nashville again, I’d return to try some of this family-owned restaurant’s more distinctive flapjack creations—unless, of course, the wait is longer than 10 minutes.
Locate the Two Diamond Pancake Pantry with TripTik Travel Planner and more information with AAA's Nashville Travel Guide.

About the Author

  • Image Maria White Maria White regularly jets from her Orlando home base to various high-profile destinations,...

Comments (2)

Submitted by Greg Weekes, January 29. 2010 16:43
This place sounds pretty good. But your point about expecting something a little more unique from a neighborhood eatery (from a flapjack point of view, that is) than a national chain is well taken. At a place called the Pancake Pantry I would expect pancakes nothing short of awesome.

And I share your opinion about IHOP. It's not bad at all. A couple of months ago I ordered a stack of four buttermilk pancakes at an IHOP. The kindly waitress asked if I wanted strawberry syrup on top. I immediately responded "yes," because it sounded yummy. When she brought out the pancakes I was aghast, because the "syrup" oozing in every direction was the candy-red color of fake blood in a cheapo slasher flick. And it was waaaaay too sweet. I immediately regretted my decision, since IHOP's regular maple syrup is perfectly acceptable. I ended up removing as much of the cherry-red, semi-liquid substance as I could. But you know what? I wasn't in Orlando, where I live. If this had happened in Orlando I would have taken to my bed in a funk for the rest of the day. But I was in an infinitely cooler place -- Santa Rosa outside of San Francisco -- so a little synthetic dayglo imitation strawberry syrup couldn't dampen my spirits. Yay!
Submitted by Maria White, February 5. 2010 17:09
Well, even though a few people I know would chastise me for liking IHOP, I'm not ashamed! But, I definitely go for the old-fashioned maple syrup every time.

The Pancake Pantry seems like the kind of place where strawberry topping would actually be made out of (shocker!) fresh strawberries, so it does have that non-high-fructose corn syrup kind of charm.

Add comment

 
 
 
  • Comment*
  • |
  • Preview






Thank you for your comment. Comments are posted as soon as possible after review and, while they are not edited, comments containing profanity, vulgarity, personal attacks or commercial content will not be published.



Recent Comments

Comment RSS



Meet Our Contributors